Import your Etsy reviews to Shopify, get verified purchase badges, and build social proof that converts.
Bring your Etsy social proof to Shopify automatically
Stop manually copying reviews between platforms. OrderBridge automatically imports your Etsy reviews, lets you moderate them, and pushes them to Judge.me where they'll display beautifully on your Shopify store.
When you use OrderBridge's delayed import feature, your reviews can be marked as "Verified Purchase" in Judge.me. This verification badge dramatically increases buyer trust and conversion rates.
Import your entire Etsy review history to Shopify in minutes. No more starting from zero when you expand to Shopify. Your satisfied customers' reviews follow you, giving new visitors confidence to buy.
Manage all your reviews from one place. OrderBridge pulls Etsy reviews, you moderate them in OrderBridge, then push to Judge.me where they display on your Shopify store. One workflow, multiple platforms.
What you need before setting up the integration
Install Judge.me from the Shopify App Store before configuring OrderBridge integration. Complete Judge.me's initial setup in your Shopify store and verify Judge.me is active and working on your store.
Gathering your Judge.me credentials and connecting to OrderBridge
The complete review import workflow
Based on your polling schedule, OrderBridge checks for new reviews on your Etsy shop
All new Etsy reviews appear in the "Pending" area for your review
Review content, decide which to accept or reject based on quality and appropriateness
Approved reviews move to "Accepted" status, ready to push to Judge.me
Push reviews manually (one at a time) or in batch for efficient importing
Manual Push: Review each individual Etsy review and push to Judge.me when ready. Useful for careful curation, slower but more controlled.
Batch Push: Select multiple accepted reviews and push all at once to Judge.me. Faster for high-volume imports, efficient for importing Etsy review history.
Best Practice: Use batch push for initial import of existing Etsy reviews, then use manual push for ongoing review moderation as new reviews come in.
Why delayed import matters for verified purchase badges
Orders created with real customer emails from the start
Orders created with placeholder emails
The Judge.me Sync Problem: Judge.me syncs orders from Shopify when they're first created. If your order was created with a placeholder email, Judge.me stores that placeholder in their database. Even if you later update the Shopify order with the real email, Judge.me doesn't automatically re-sync that change.
The Solution: Delayed Import. By using delayed import with the browser extension, orders are created in Shopify with real customer emails from the start. Judge.me syncs the correct email on first import, so verification works automatically when reviews are pushed.
Troubleshooting tips for Judge.me integration
This happens when orders were created with placeholder emails. Judge.me synced the placeholder and won't update automatically. Solution: Use delayed import with browser extension going forward. For existing orders, reviews will still publish, just not verified.
Go back to Judge.me → Integrations → View API Token. Verify you copied the complete Private API Token. Ensure no extra spaces were copied. Token should start with jdg_. Make sure you're using the Private API Token, not any other token.
Use your full Shopify domain including .myshopify.com. Don't use a custom domain - use the Shopify one. Example: your-store.myshopify.com not www.yourstore.com
Check that reviews were marked as "Accepted" in OrderBridge. Verify the product SKU matches between Etsy and Shopify. Check Judge.me dashboard for any errors or pending approvals. Ensure products are properly mapped in OrderBridge.
No, Judge.me doesn't allow manual verification. Verification is automatic based on email matching. Judge.me support: "We don't manually mark reviews as Verified. Verification is applied automatically." Solution: Use delayed import to get automatic verification.
Maximize the value of your Judge.me integration
1. Judge.me app
2. Integrations (left sidebar)
3. View API Token (top right)
4. Copy Shop Domain
5. Copy Private API Token
1. OrderBridge dashboard
2. Settings → Judge.me Integration
3. Paste Shop Domain
4. Paste Private API Token
5. Save
1. OrderBridge polls Etsy
2. Reviews appear in Pending
3. Moderate and accept reviews
4. Push to Judge.me (manual or batch)
5. If delayed import used → verified ✓
6. If not → still published, not verified
Day 0: Order created with real email
Day 0: Judge.me syncs order
Day 7-14: Customer leaves Etsy review
Day 14+: Review pushed to Judge.me
Day 14+: Judge.me sends verification
Day 14+: Customer confirms
Result: Verified review ✓
No credit card required • Import unlimited reviews during trial